Israel and Egypt Discuss Potential Hostage Release Deal as Hopes Rise for Negotiations with Hamas

Israeli security officials have recently been in Cairo to discuss efforts to secure a deal for the release of hostages held by Hamas in Gaza. Shin Bet Director Ronen Bar and IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi met with senior Egyptian officials on Tuesday, signaling growing optimism about reaching an agreement, according to Israeli sources.

The meeting, which had been scheduled weeks in advance, was originally focused on issues related to the Gaza-Egypt border. However, the ongoing hostage situation also took center stage, with Israeli officials now more hopeful that Hamas may be willing to engage in talks. “Two weeks ago I thought Hamas didn’t want a deal,” one official stated, “Now I am inclined to think that it has changed its mind.”

The possibility of a breakthrough in negotiations has grown following several months of stalled talks and tense regional dynamics. Israeli officials believe that the weakening of Hamas’ alliances and internal pressure may encourage the group to reconsider its position on a potential deal. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu emphasized that Hamas is “more isolated than ever,” citing the collapse of fronts with Syria, Hezbollah, and Iran as contributing factors.

Moreover, recent regional developments, including former US President Donald Trump’s warning of “hell to pay” if hostages are not released before his inauguration, have injected new momentum into the talks. While some reports suggest that Hamas has yet to confirm its willingness to negotiate, sources indicate that the terror group has provided a list of living hostages to Egyptian mediators, signaling a potential shift in its stance.

Despite these hopeful signs, significant obstacles remain. One of the main sticking points is Hamas’ demand for a permanent end to the war and the withdrawal of Israeli troops from Gaza in exchange for releasing hostages. Israel, however, has insisted on maintaining a military presence in Gaza and is wary of agreeing to long-term ceasefires.

Recent proposals from Egyptian mediators have suggested a phased Israeli withdrawal from Gaza during a ceasefire that could last up to two months, with the first phase involving the release of elderly, women, children, and critically wounded hostages. During this period, the sides would aim to negotiate a more permanent resolution to the conflict.

The United States is also actively involved in these discussions. US National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby reiterated the US position that a deal with Hamas is still possible, and National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan is set to visit Israel to further facilitate progress. Despite differing views among international mediators, such as Qatar and Egypt, who have called for an end to the war as part of the deal, the US continues to push for a resolution that ensures the return of hostages without compromising Israel’s security.